Skip to main content

PART IV: From Insights To Solution

PART IV: From Insights To Solution

"Analysis tells you what matters. Strategy tells you what to do about it."

The purpose of case analysis is not to produce an impressive collection of facts, frameworks, charts, and observations. The purpose is to build a better decision.

At this point in the case-solving process, your team should have developed a reasonably strong understanding of:

  • the organisation;
  • the business model;
  • the customers and stakeholders;
  • the external environment;
  • the competitive environment;
  • the organisation's capabilities;
  • the central problem;
  • the underlying causes;
  • the opportunities and constraints.

Now comes the difficult part. What should the organisation actually do? This is where many teams lose the connection between analysis and recommendation. They generate a few ideas. They choose one. Then they try to justify it.

Strong teams work differently. They allow the analysis to generate the alternatives. They establish criteria for evaluating those alternatives. They test the alternatives against the evidence. They consider the customer and stakeholder experience. They examine financial and strategic implications. And then they make a decision. This is the transition from: Understanding the case to Solving the case. 

PART IV CLOSING: From Insight to Choice

Part IV represents one of the most important transitions in case solving. You began with:

Understanding people and moved through:

Customer journeys à Strategic alternatives à Decision criteria à Financial feasibility à Strategic choice

The process should feel connected. Your persona should inform the problem.

ü  Your analysis should inform the alternatives.

ü  Your alternatives should inform the criteria.

ü  Your criteria should inform the decision.

ü  Your financial analysis should test the decision.

ü  Your final strategy should bring the pieces together.

That is what makes a recommendation feel inevitable rather than debatable.

The Discover Your Mad Skills Solution Chain

Use this chain whenever you feel your case is becoming fragmented:

1. What is the problem?                                          Define à 

2. Who experiences it?                                            Understand à

3. Why is it happening?    Analyse↓

4. What could we do?                                              Generate à

5. Which choices are realistic?                                 Develop Alternatives à 

6. Which choice is best?                                          Evaluate à 

7. Does it create enough value?                             Test à 

8. What strategic choice does this create?             Decide à 

9. How will we make it happen?                            Implement

The Final Test

Before moving into implementation, your team should be able to answer these questions clearly:

ü  What problem are we solving?

ü  For whom?

ü  What is causing the problem?

ü  What alternatives did we consider?

ü  Why does our chosen alternative win?

ü  What evidence supports it?

ü  What financial value does it create?

ü  Why does it fit this organisation

ü  What strategic choices are we making?

If you cannot answer these questions, you aren't ready to build the implementation plan.

Deciphering Case Characteristics

Not every case requires every tool in this section.

  • A customer-focused case may need detailed personas and journey mapping.
  • A strategic decision may require robust alternatives and decision criteria.
  • A financially focused case may require deeper feasibility analysis.
  • A transformation case may require a strong strategic choice before moving into implementation.

The tools are not a checklist. They are lenses. The characteristics of the case determine which lenses you need.

The Mad Skills Rule

Don't build a solution because it sounds good.

Build a solution because the evidence makes it the best choice.

And then make that choice clear enough that the judges can see the logic for themselves. That is how you move from: Analysis to Insight to Choice to Strategy. And that is where a case solution begins to become podium-ready.

Back to top