Skip to main content

Chapter 12: Value Chain Analysis - Finding Where Value Is Created, Lost, and Strengthened

Video:Video: Value Chain Analysis: TheFind Underused Tool That Reveals How to ImproveWhere Your Client'sBusiness OperationsCreates Value—and Where It Loses It

Learning Objectives

By the end of this chapter, you should be able to:

  • define

    explain the valuepurpose anof organisationValue isChain tryingAnalysis;

    to create for its customers;
  • identify the

    distinguish between primary and support activitiesactivities;

    involved in delivering that value;
  • distinguish activities

    identify fromwhere capabilitiesan andorganisation outcomes;creates customer value;

  • identify sourceswhere ofcosts, cost,delays, quality,inefficiencies, speed,or service,performance andgaps differentiation;occur;

  • recognise bottlenecks, duplication, delays, and operational weaknesses;
  • understand how activities andinteract organisationalacross functionsthe arevalue connected;chain;

  • trace visible

    distinguish performance problems back to their operational causes;

  • identifybetween activities that maycreate contributevalue toand competitiveactivities advantage;that simply consume resources;

  • evaluate

    identify opportunities to strengthen,strengthen differentiation or reduce cost;

  • connect value chain findings to organisational capabilities;

  • identify potential opportunities for redesign, automate,automation, outsource,outsourcing, integration, or integrateinvestment;

    activities;
  • prioritise value chain improvements based on strategic impact and feasibility; and

  • translate value chain analysis into strategic recommendations.


Why This Matters

An organisation does not create value in one place.

Value is created—or lost—across a series of activities.

A company may have an excellent product but poor distribution.

It may have strong customer relationships but inefficient operations.

It may have low production costs but weak marketing.

It may deliver exceptional service but destroy value through an unnecessarily expensive operating model.

The important question is therefore not simply:

What does the company do?

It is:

Where, across everything the company does, is value being created, lost, or strengthened?

That is the purpose of Value Chain findings into practical strategic recommendations.

Why This MattersAnalysis.

OrganisationsIt don'thelps createyou valuemove throughinside onethe activity.organisation Aand productexamine doesn't become valuable simply because it has been manufactured. A service doesn't create value simply because an employee has delivered it. Value emerges from a connected system of activities. For many businesses, thosehow activities include:contribute to:

  • identifying

    customer needs;value;

  • sourcing inputs;

    cost;

  • designing products

    quality;

    or services;
  • producing or

    speed;

    delivering the offering;
  • moving it

    reliability;

    to the customer;
  • communicating its

    differentiation;

    value;
  • completing the

    competitive sale;advantage; and

  • supporting the

    ultimately, customerprofitability.

    after purchase.

Behind


these activities are systems involving:

  • people;
  • technology;
  • procurement;
  • organisational infrastructure;
  • data;
  • finance;
  • management.

A failure in one activity can affect everything that follows. Poor forecasting may create inventory shortages. Inventory shortages may cause delivery delays. Delivery delays may increase customer-service complaints. Complaints may increase refunds and reduce customer retention. Lower retention may increase the pressure on marketing to acquire replacement customers. What appears to be a marketing problem may have originated in forecasting. What appears to be a customer-service problem may have begun in product design or operations. Value Chain Analysis helps teams understand:

  • how value is created;
  • which activities contribute most to that value;
  • where cost or performance problems originate;
  • how activities affect one another;
  • where strategic improvement could have the greatest impact.

The objective is not simply to map what the organisation does. It is to understand how well the organisation's activities work together to deliver value to the customer.

Discover Your MAD Skills Principle

Don't just map the activities. Find the activities that change the economics of the business.

A weak value chain analysis simply lists activities:

"The company buys materials, produces the product, markets it, sells it, and provides customer service."

That is a description.

A stronger analysis asks:

Don’tWhich askactivities onlycreate whatvalue for the organisation does. Ask where it creates value, where it loses value, and why.customer?

Listing activities is not enough. "Procurement, operations, logistics, marketing, and service" tells us how the company is organised. It doesn't tell us:

  • which activities matter most to the customer;
  • whichWhich activities create unnecessary cost;
  • where delayscost or qualityfriction?

    problems
originate;
  • which

    Which activities differentiateare thestrategically company;

  • important?

  • how
  • one
    activity

    Where affectsis another;performance

  • below what shouldcustomers beexpect?

    changed.
  • AWhich usefulactivities could create a meaningful competitive advantage?

    That is analysis.


    What Is Value Chain insight follows this progression: Customer value → Activity → Performance Gap → Downstream Impact → Strategic Improvement. For example, customers value reliable next-day delivery, but inaccurate demand forecasting leads to stockouts. Those stockouts delay fulfilment, increase expedited shipping costs, and reduce customer satisfaction. Improving forecasting would therefore strengthen both operational efficiency and the customer experience. That is more useful than saying the organisation needs to "improve logistics."

    Analysis?

    WhereMichael Porter's Value Chain Analysisseparates Fitsan organisation into the activities involved in creating, delivering, and supporting its products or services.

    The traditional model divides activities into two broad categories:

    Primary Activities

    Activities directly involved in creating and delivering the offering:

    1. Inbound Logistics

    2. Operations

    3. Outbound Logistics

    4. Marketing & Sales

    5. Service

    Support Activities

    Activities that enable the primary activities to function effectively:

    1. Firm Infrastructure

    2. Human Resource Management

    3. Technology Development

    4. Procurement

    The framework is useful because it forces us to look beyond the final product.

    Customers experience the outcome of the entire system.


    The Value Chain

    Primary ActivitiesWhat to Examine
    Inbound LogisticsReceiving, storing, and managing inputs
    OperationsConverting inputs into the product or service
    Outbound LogisticsDistribution and delivery
    Marketing & SalesCreating demand and converting customers
    ServiceSupporting customers after purchase
    Support ActivitiesWhat to Examine
    Firm InfrastructureFinance, planning, legal, governance, administration
    Human ResourcesRecruiting, training, development, incentives
    Technology DevelopmentSystems, data, R&D, automation, innovation
    ProcurementSourcing and purchasing inputs and services

    The categories are useful starting points.

    But do not become trapped by the traditional diagram.

    A service business, software company, hospital, university, or nonprofit may have very different activities.

    The objective is to understand how value actually flows through that organisation.


    Deciphering Case Characteristics

    Value Chain Analysis is primarilyparticularly anuseful internalwhen analysisa tool.case involves:

    • declining margins;

    • high operating costs;

    • poor customer experience;

    • inconsistent quality;

    • supply chain problems;

    • operational inefficiencies;

    • slow delivery;

    • service problems;

    • competitive differentiation;

    • outsourcing decisions;

    • automation;

    • vertical integration;

    • process redesign;

    • productivity improvements; or

    • questions about where the organisation should invest.

    It examinesis especially valuable when the case asks:

    Why is the company struggling to create value despite having a good product or strong market position?


    The Value Chain Question

    Before mapping the activities, define:

    What does the customer actually value?

    For example, customers may value:

    • low price;

    • speed;

    • convenience;

    • reliability;

    • customisation;

    • quality;

    • availability;

    • service;

    • trust; or

    • experience.

    Once you know what customers value, you can examine how aneach organisationactivity performscontributes to delivering it.


    Step 1: Identify the Customer Value Proposition

    Start with the customer's perspective.

    Ask:

    Why does the customer choose this organisation?

    Suppose a company competes on:

    Fast, reliable delivery of customised products.

    That immediately tells you what the value chain needs to support.

    You should now examine:

    • procurement;

    • production;

    • inventory;

    • scheduling;

    • logistics;

    • technology;

    • customer communication; and

    • service.

    A slow process anywhere in that chain could undermine the entire value proposition.


    Step 2: Map the Activities

    Identify the activities required to create and deliver a product or service. It is particularly valuable when a case involves:

    • high operating costs;
    • declining margins;
    • service-quality problems;
    • production delays;
    • supply-chain challenges;
    • inconsistent customer experiences;
    • inventory problems;
    • productivity;
    • process redesign;
    • outsourcing;
    • automation;
    • vertical integration;
    • operational scaling;
    • differentiation;
    • the development of competitive advantage.

    Value Chain Analysis may be less useful when the casevalue is focused primarily on:proposition.

      Do

    • macro-environmentalnot trends;
    • automatically
    • industry attractiveness;
    • broad stakeholder conflict;
    • organisational culture;
    • a narrow financial decision with little operational impact.

    Even then, findings from PESTLE, Five Forces, customer analysis, and financial analysis may reveal where Value Chain investigation is needed. For example:

    • Five Forces may reveal strong supplier power.
    • Value Chain Analysis can then examine procurement, supplier management, and input design.
    • Customer analysis may reveal frustration with delivery.
    • Value Chain Analysis can trace that problem through forecasting, inventory, fulfilment, and logistics.
    • Financial analysis may reveal declining margins.
    • Value Chain Analysis can locatecopy the activitiestextbook responsible for rising costs.

    The case characteristics should determine whether Value Chain Analysis is the right tool.categories.

    BeginInstead, with the Customer

    Before mappingmap the organisation's activities,actual defineprocess.

    For example:

    Supplier → Receiving → Production → Quality Control → Distribution → Customer → Service

    Then identify the support systems behind those activities:

    People + Technology + Procurement + Finance + Management

    Now you can begin asking where value is created or lost.


    Step 3: Evaluate Each Activity

    For every major activity, ask five questions:

    1. Does it create customer value?

    Does the organisation is trying to create. Ask what the customer actually values. Depending on the organisation, customers may value:

    • low price;
    • quality;
    • reliability;
    • speed;
    • convenience;
    • customisation;
    • accessibility;
    • safety;
    • expertise;
    • trust;
    • status;
    • innovation;
    • responsiveness;
    • a distinctive experience.

    Different customer segments may value different things. A business traveller may value schedule flexibility and reliability. A leisure traveller may prioritise price. A hospital may value supplier consistency and regulatory compliance. An individual consumer may value convenience and design. Without understanding the customer, a team cannot determine whether an activity createsdirectly value.or Anindirectly activity doesn't create value merely because the organisation performs it. It creates value when it:

    • improvesimprove something the customer values;cares about?

      2. What does it cost?

      How much resource does the activity consume?

      3. How well does it perform?

      Consider:

      • speed;

      • enables another

        quality;

        value-creating activity;
      • meets a

        reliability;

        necessary
      • legal
      • productivity;

      • error rates;

      • customer satisfaction.

      4. Is it strategically important?

      Could this activity create differentiation or operationalcost requirement;advantage?

      5. Could it be improved?

      Could the organisation:

      • redesign it;

      • reduces cost

        automate withoutit;

        damaging
      • outsource it;

      • insource it;

      • integrate it;

      • simplify it; or

      • eliminate unnecessary steps?


      The Value Creation Test

      For each activity, ask:

      Would the customer experience.

    This leads to three categories.

    Value-Creating Activities

    These directly contribute to something customers value or arebe willing to pay for.more—or would the organisation become more competitive—because we do this activity well?

    If yes, the activity may be a source of value or differentiation.

    Value-EnablingFor Activitiesexample:

    TheseA luxury hotel's concierge service may be expensive to operate, but it contributes directly to the customer experience.

    An automated inventory system may not be visible to customerscustomers, but allowit othercan activitiesreduce tostockouts performand effectively.improve delivery reliability.

    Non-Value-CreatingNot Activitiesevery valuable activity is customer-facing.


    The Value Destruction Test

    TheseNow consumeask:

    time
    or

    Where are we spending significant resources without meaningfullycreating improvingequivalent thevalue?

    outcome
    or

    This meetingis awhere requirement.value However,chain teamsanalysis shouldbecomes beespecially careful.powerful.

    Examples include:

    • unnecessary process steps;

    • excessive inventory;

    • duplicate data entry;

    • rework;

    • inefficient transportation;

    • excessive management layers;

    • outdated technology;

    • poor scheduling;

    • avoidable customer-service contacts.

    An activity thatcan doesn'tbe directlynecessary without being performed efficiently.

    That distinction matters.


    Value Created vs. Value Captured

    Another important distinction is between creating value and capturing value.

    A company may create customersignificant value mayfor stillcustomers bebut essential.capture Regulatorylittle compliance,of cybersecurity,it.

    quality

    For assurance,example:

    A restaurant provides exceptional food and financialservice controlsbut has high labour costs, food waste, and inefficient table turnover.

    Customers may receive substantial value.

    The company may not increasecapture customers'enough willingnessof tothat pay,value butas removingprofit.

    them

    Therefore, couldask exposetwo theseparate organisationquestions:

    to

    Value seriousCreation

    risk.
    The right question is not: "Can we eliminate every activity customers don’t see?" It is: "

    Does this activity contributeimprove the customer's experience or willingness to customer value, enable value creation, or fulfil a requirement, and is it being performed efficiently?"pay?

    Understanding

    the

    Value Chain

    Capture

    Porter's original Value Chain framework divides organisational activities into two groups:

    • Primary activities;
    • Support activities.

    Primary activities are directly involved in creating, selling, delivering, and supporting the offering. Support activities enable the primary activities to operate effectively.

    The Primary Activities

    1. Inbound Logistics

    Inbound logistics includes receiving, storing, handling, and managing the inputs required to produce the offering. It may involve:

    • supplier coordination;
    • transportation;
    • receiving;
    • warehousing;
    • inventory management;
    • inspection;
    • scheduling;
    • material handling.

    Questions to ask include:

    • Are the required inputs available when needed?
    • How reliable are the suppliers?
    • Is inventory too high or too low?
    • Are inputs frequently delayed, damaged, or rejected?
    • How accurate is demand forecasting?
    • Are receiving and storage processes efficient?
    • Where do shortages or excess inventory originate?
    • Does the organisation haveretain visibility across its supply network?

    Possible problems include:

    • stockouts;
    • excess inventory;
    • high storage costs;
    • inconsistent input quality;
    • supplier delays;
    • weak forecasting;
    • dependence on a small number of suppliers.

    2. Operations

    Operations transform inputs into the final product or service. It may include:

    • manufacturing;
    • assembly;
    • service delivery;
    • scheduling;
    • quality control;
    • packaging;
    • facility management;
    • process management;
    • capacity planning.

    Questions to ask include:

    • Where are the bottlenecks?
    • How fully is capacity being used?
    • Are processes standardised?
    • How frequently do errors or defects occur?
    • Is work being duplicated?
    • Are employees waiting for information, materials, or approvals?
    • Does the process consistently meet customer expectations?
    • Could technology improve speed, quality, or reliability?

    Possible problems include:

    • low productivity;
    • poor quality;
    • rework;
    • downtime;
    • underused capacity;
    • excessive approval layers;
    • inconsistent service;
    • process delays.

    3. Outbound Logistics

    Outbound logistics includes storing, fulfilling, distributing, and delivering the finished product or service to the customer. It may involve:

    • order processing;
    • fulfilment;
    • finished-goods inventory;
    • transportation;
    • distribution;
    • delivery scheduling;
    • digital delivery;
    • channel coordination.

    Questions to ask include:

    • How quickly and reliably are orders fulfilled?
    • Where do delivery delays occur?
    • Are fulfilment errors common?
    • Does the distribution model match customer expectations?
    • How much does delivery cost?
    • Are channel partners helping or limiting performance?
    • Does the organisation have accurate order visibility?
    • Are returns handled efficiently?

    Possible problems include:

    • slow delivery;
    • incorrect orders;
    • high transportation costs;
    • fragmented distribution;
    • damaged products;
    • poor order visibility;
    • inefficient returns.

    4. Marketing and Sales

    Marketing and sales help customers understand the offering, select it, and complete the purchase. Activities may include:

    • market research;
    • segmentation;
    • branding;
    • promotion;
    • pricing;
    • lead generation;
    • sales;
    • channel management;
    • customer education;
    • contract negotiation.

    Questions to ask include:

    • Is the value proposition clear?
    • Is the organisation reaching the right customers?
    • How much does it cost to acquire a customer?
    • Which channels produce the strongest results?
    • Does marketing make promises operations can deliver?
    • Is pricing aligned with customer value?
    • Are sales incentives encouraging the right behaviour?
    • Where are potential customers dropping out of the sales process?

    Possible problems include:

    • unclear positioning;
    • high customer-acquisition cost;
    • poor targeting;
    • channel conflict;
    • weak conversion;
    • discount dependence;
    • inconsistent messaging;
    • promises that operations cannot fulfil.

    5. Service

    Service includes the activities that maintain or increase the value of the offering after the sale. It may include:

    • installation;
    • onboarding;
    • training;
    • customer support;
    • maintenance;
    • repairs;
    • returns;
    • complaint resolution;
    • account management;
    • customer-success activities.

    Questions to ask include:

    • What are the most common customer problems?
    • How quickly are issues resolved?
    • Can employees solve problems without unnecessary escalation?
    • Are complaints used to improve earlier activities?
    • Does service increase retention and loyalty?
    • Are customers receiving the support they expected?
    • Could self-service improve convenience?
    • Where does service recover or further damage the customer relationship?

    Possible problems include:

    • slow response times;
    • repeated complaints;
    • poor first-contact resolution;
    • weak onboarding;
    • high return rates;
    • inconsistent support;
    • fragmented customer information;
    • failure to learn from customer feedback.

    The Support Activities

    Support activities strengthen or enable the primary activities.

    1. Organisational Infrastructure

    Infrastructure includes the systems that coordinate and govern the organisation. It may involve:

    • leadership;
    • strategy;
    • finance;
    • planning;
    • legal;
    • governance;
    • risk management;
    • performance measurement;
    • organisational structure.

    Questions to ask include:

    • Are responsibilities and decision rights clear?
    • Do teams have the information needed to make decisions?
    • Are incentives aligned with organisational objectives?
    • Do performance measures encourage the right behaviour?
    • Are approvals creating unnecessary delays?
    • Does the organisational structure support the strategy?
    • Are resources allocated to the highest-priority activities?

    Infrastructure problems often appear in other partsenough of the value chain as:

    • slow decisions;
    • conflicting priorities;
    • unclear accountability;
    • weak coordination; and appear
    • poor resource allocation.

    2. Human Resource Management

    Human resource management includes:

    • recruitment;
    • selection;
    • onboarding;
    • training;
    • scheduling;
    • performance management;
    • compensation;
    • retention;
    • workforce planning;
    • employee development.

    Questionscreated to askgenerate include:attractive returns?

    • Does the organisation have the skills it needs?
    • Are critical roles difficult to fill?
    • Is turnover damaging service or productivity?
    • Are employees trained to perform consistently?
    • Are incentives aligned with customer and operational outcomes?
    • Does scheduling match demand?
    • Are employees empowered to solve problems?
    • Which activities depend heavily on specialised talent?

    PeopleThat problems frequently become customer problems. Weak onboarding, poor scheduling, misaligned incentives, or insufficient trainingdistinction can affectuncover quality,important speed,strategic service, and cost throughout the value chain.problems.

    3.


    Technology

    Finding Development

    Performance Gaps

    Technology development includes the systems, tools, data, and innovation that support the organisation's activities. It may involve:

    • information systems;
    • automation;
    • product development;
    • artificial intelligence;
    • analytics;
    • digital platforms;
    • cybersecurity;
    • process technology;
    • research and development.

    Questions to ask include:

    • Where is work still being completed manually?
    • Are systems integrated?
    • Can employees access accurate information?
    • Is data being collected but not used?
    • Could automation reduce errors or delays?
    • Does the technology improve the customer experience?
    • What new capabilities would implementation require?
    • Could technology create new operational or cybersecurity risks?

    Technology should not be treated as an automatic solution. A poorly designed process doesn't become effective simply because it is automated.

    4. Procurement

    Procurement includes acquiring the products, services, equipment, and resources needed throughout the value chain. It may involve:

    • supplier selection;
    • contracting;
    • purchasing;
    • negotiation;
    • supplier evaluation;
    • category management;
    • make-or-buy decisions.

    Questions to ask include:

    • Is the organisation buying the right inputs?
    • Are suppliers evaluated on more than price?
    • How concentrated is the supplier base?
    • Are contracts aligned with performance requirements?
    • Could purchasing be consolidated?
    • Are supplier relationships transactional or strategic?
    • Could another supplier improve cost, quality, or innovation?
    • Should the organisation produce the input internally?

    Procurement is related to but not identical to inbound logistics. Procurement decides what to buy, from whom, and under what terms. Inbound logistics manages the physical or informational flow of those inputs into the organisation.

    Don't Force a Manufacturing Model onto Every Organisation

    Porter's original activity categories are useful, but they should be adapted to the organisation.

    ·        A professional-services firm may have auseful value chain suchanalysis as: Client acquisition → Diagnosis → Solution design → Project delivery → Knowledge transfer → Relationship management.compares:

    ·Expected APerformance universityvs. mightActual have: Student recruitment → Admissions → Program design → Teaching → Student support → Assessment → Alumni engagementPerformance

    ·For Aexample:

    healthcareprovidermighthave:Patient→→Treatmentplanning→Care →→Follow-up.
    Activity Customer/Business accessExpectation Actual DiagnosisPerformance Gap
    ProcurementReliable supplyFrequent shortagesHigh
    Operations48-hour production72 hoursHigh
    DistributionNext-day delivery 2–3 Dischargedays High
    ServiceSame-day response48 hoursMedium

    The gaps tell you where to investigate further.

    ·But Aa digitalgap platformdoes mightnot have:automatically Usertell acquisitionyou →the Onboardingroot → Engagement → Transaction or interaction → Support → Retentioncause.

    ·That Arequires not-for-profitdeeper mightanalysis.

    have:
    Funding

    Root →Cause: ProgramDon't designFix →the ParticipantSymptom

    recruitment

    Suppose →customers Servicecomplain deliveryabout →late Outcome measurement → Donor and stakeholder reportingdeliveries.

    TheA goalweak analysis says:

    Problem: Distribution is too slow.

    A stronger analysis asks:

    Why are deliveries late?

    Perhaps:

    Late deliveries

    ↓

    Production schedules are frequently changed

    ↓

    Production lacks accurate demand forecasts

    ↓

    Sales information is not tointegrated forcewith everyoperations

    ↓

    The company uses disconnected systems

    Now the apparent logistics problem may actually be a technology and information-flow problem.

    That changes the solution.

    The organisation intomay thenot sameneed labels.more Thetrucks.

    goal

    It ismay toneed mapbetter thedata activities that actually createintegration and deliver value.planning.


    Value Chain Activities Are NotConnected

    Capabilities

    One of the most important lessons is that activities do not operate independently.

    An activity is something an organisation does. A capability is how well the organisation can perform an activity or consistently coordinate several activities. For example:

    • Delivering products is an activity. Delivering products faster and more reliably than competitors is a capability.
    • Collecting customer data is an activity. Using customer data to personalise service and improve retention is a capability.
    • Buying materials is an activity. Building supplier partnerships that improve quality and innovation is a capability.

    This distinction matters because competitive advantage rarely comes from merely performing an activity. Most competitors perform similar activities. Advantage comes from:

    • performing an activity at lower cost;
    • performing it more effectively;
    • performing it distinctively;
    • connecting activities in a way competitors struggle to replicate.

    Analyse the Connections, Not Just the Activities

    The value chain is a system. Activities are connected through flows of:

    • materials;
    • information;
    • decisions;
    • money;
    • employees;
    • technology;
    • customer feedback.

    A changeproblem in one activity can create consequencesproblems elsewhere.

    For example:

    Procurement

    Poor selectsprocurement

    a

    ↓

    lower-cost

    Inconsistent supplierraw →materials

    input

    ↓

    Production delays

    ↓

    Lower product quality

    declines

    ↓

    → production defects increase → deliveries are delayed →

    More customer complaints

    rise

    ↓

    →

    Higher service costs

    increase

    The →initial brand trust declines. Procurementproblem appears to havebe reduceda cost,procurement but the total cost has increased. Connections can also create positive reinforcement: Better customer data → more accurate forecasting → fewer stockouts → more reliable delivery → higher satisfaction → stronger retention → lower customer-acquisition pressure.issue.

    The greatestfinancial opportunity for improvement may not exist within a single activity. It may exist in the handoff between two activities. Ask:

    • Where is information lost?
    • Where does work wait?
    • Where are responsibilities unclear?
    • Where is the same information entered repeatedly?
    • Where does one team optimise its own performance at the expense of another?
    • Where do customer complaints fail to reach the activity that caused them?
    • Where do incentives create conflicting behaviour?

    The visible problem oftenimpact appears downstream from its cause.

    From Symptom to Root Cause

    Suppose a company has a rising number of customer complaints. A weak recommendation might be to hire more customer service employees. Value Chain Analysis asks whether customer service is the source of the problem or merely where the problem becomes visible. The team might trace complaints to:

    • inaccurate marketing claims;
    • product defects;
    • incomplete onboarding;
    • fulfilment errors;
    • delayed delivery;
    • confusing billing;
    • weak employee training;
    • fragmented customer information.

    Hiring more service employees may help manage volume, but it will not necessarily address the root cause. A practical diagnostic chain is Symptom → Affected Activity → Upstream Cause → Downstream Consequence → Root-Cause Response. For example: Customer complaints are rising → service is receiving more delivery inquiries → inaccurate inventory data causes orders to be accepted when products are unavailable → fulfilment delays increase → customers contact service repeatedly → integrate inventory and ordering systems rather than simply expanding the service team. The recommendation becomes specific because the analysis has located the cause.

    Finding Cost Advantage

    Value Chain Analysis can reveal where an organisation may reduce cost without damaging customer value. Potential cost drivers include:

    • scale;
    • capacity utilisation;
    • labour intensity;
    • process complexity;
    • rework;
    • error rates;
    • supplier terms;
    • inventory levels;
    • transportation;
    • technology;
    • coordination;
    • product variety;
    • duplicated activities.

    Ask:

    • Which activities consume the most resources?
    • Where are costs increasing?
    • Which costs are driven by errors or rework?
    • Where is capacity unused?
    • Which activities are duplicated?
    • Where do delays create expediting costs?
    • Are expensive activities important to customers?
    • Could the process be simplified?
    • Could technology reduce cost without reducing value?
    • Would changing one activity increase cost elsewhere?

    Don't recommend general cost reduction. Identify:

    • the activity;
    • the cost driver;
    • the proposed change;
    • the expected savings;
    • the effect on other activities;
    • the potential effect on the customer.

    For example: Automating order entry could reduce administrative labour and data-entry errors, but the company must preserve access to human support for complex institutional customers. This recognises both efficiency and customer value.

    Finding Differentiation Advantage

    Value Chain Analysis is not only a cost-reduction tool. Activities may also create differentiation through:

    • quality;
    • reliability;
    • speed;
    • convenience;
    • customisation;
    • customer experience;
    • innovation;
    • service;
    • trust;
    • sustainability;
    • integration.

    Ask:

    • Which activities matter most to the target customer?
    • Where does the organisation perform differently from competitors?
    • Which activities supportthroughout the value proposition?
    • chain.

    • What part of the customer experience

      This is difficultwhy tovalue copy?

    • chain
    • Couldanalysis bettershould coordinationbe createviewed as a distinctivesystem, experience?
    • not
    • Whicha supportlist.


      The Connection Test

      For each significant problem, ask:

      What other activity enablesdoes thethis differentiation?

    • affect?

    • Is the

      Then customerask:

      willing
      to

      What paycaused forthis theproblem differenceupstream?

      or

      And:

      What consequence does it improvecreate retention?

    • downstream?

    ForThis example:helps reveal leverage points.

    A healthcaresmall supplierimprovement upstream may notcreate differentiatesignificant throughbenefits throughout the product itself. Its advantage may come from dependable inventory, rapid delivery, regulatory expertise, and responsive account management. The difference comes from a connected system of activities rather than from a single isolated feature.system.

    From


    Core

    Cost Activities to Core Competencies

    Advantage

    Value Chain Analysis can help surfaceidentify capabilitiesopportunities to reduce cost.

    But the objective should not simply be:

    Cut costs.

    The better question is:

    Which costs can be reduced without damaging customer value or strategic capability?

    Potential opportunities include:

    • reducing waste;

    • automating repetitive work;

    • consolidating purchasing;

    • redesigning processes;

    • improving inventory management;

    • reducing rework;

    • optimising transportation;

    • eliminating duplication.

    A cost reduction that damages quality or customer experience may becomedestroy coremore competencies.value Ask:than it creates.


      Differentiation Advantage

      The value chain can also reveal where an organisation can differentiate itself.

      Potential sources include:

      • What does

        superior product quality;

      • faster delivery;

      • better customer service;

      • greater customisation;

      • better technology;

      • stronger relationships;

      • superior reliability;

      • unique purchasing capabilities.

      The key question is:

      Which activities allow the organisation to do exceptionallysomething well?customers

    1. Whichvalue activitiesbetter orthan combinationscompetitors?

      of
    2. activities

      That is where value chain analysis connects with competitive advantage.


      Linking the Value Chain to VRIO

      An activity being performed well does not automatically create thatsustainable capability?competitive

    3. advantage.

      Ask:

      Is the underlying capability valuable?

      Is it rare?

      Is it difficult to imitate?

      Is the organisation structured to capture the value?

      Those are VRIO questions.

      For example:

      A company may have an excellent logistics process.

      If every competitor can purchase the same logistics technology and hire the same providers, the capability importantmay tocreate customers?

    4. temporary
    5. Doesefficiency itbut improvenot cost,a quality,sustainable speed,advantage.

      reliability,

      The orvalue differentiation?

    6. chain
    7. Cantells competitorsyou easily replicate it?
    8. Canwhere the organisationcapability apply it to new products, customers, or markets?
    operates.

    For example: A retailer's core competency may not be "logistics." It may be the ability to combine:

    • supplier data;
    • demand forecasting;
    • inventory visibility;
    • distribution capacity;
    • store-level execution

    to maintain product availability at a lower cost than competitors. Value Chain AnalysisVRIO helps identifydetermine the system of activities producing the capability. The next chapter's VRIO analysis can then test whether that capability can create sustained competitiveadvantage.

    advantage.

    Improving the Value Chain

    Once you identify important gaps, consider the strategic levers available.

    Redesign

    Change how the activity is performed.

    PrioritisingExample:

    Improvement
    Opportunities

    Redesign order processing to eliminate duplicate approvals.

    Automation

    Use technology to reduce manual work.

    NotExample:

    every

    Automate inventory replenishment based on demand data.

    Outsourcing

    Use an external specialist.

    Example:

    Outsource non-core logistics to a specialist provider.

    Insourcing

    Bring a strategically important activity deservesin-house.

    equal

    Example:

    attention.

    Develop internal data analytics capabilities rather than relying entirely on external consultants.

    Integration

    Connect activities that currently operate independently.

    Example:

    Integrate sales forecasts with production planning.

    Elimination

    Remove an activity that creates little value.

    Example:

    Eliminate redundant reporting that does not influence decisions.

    Investment

    Strengthen an activity that is strategically important.

    Example:

    Invest in customer-service technology because service quality is central to the company's differentiation strategy.


    A Worked Example: Meal-Kit Company

    Imagine a meal-kit company that has strong customer demand but declining profitability.

    The company initially assumes the problem is marketing.

    A value chain analysis reveals something different.

    Procurement

    The company purchases ingredients from multiple suppliers.

    Problem: Limited purchasing coordination creates inconsistent pricing.

    Inbound Logistics

    Ingredients arrive at several facilities.

    Problem: Poor scheduling creates excess inventory and spoilage.

    Operations

    Meals are assembled and packaged.

    Problem: High labour requirements and inconsistent processes create rework.

    Outbound Logistics

    Orders are delivered directly to customers.

    Problem: Last-mile delivery costs are high.

    Marketing & Sales

    Customer acquisition is strong.

    Strength: Effective digital marketing generates demand.

    Service

    Customer complaints are increasing.

    Problem: Many complaints relate to missing or incorrect ingredients.

    Now connect the activities:

    Poor procurement coordination

    ↓

    Inconsistent inventory

    ↓

    Production substitutions and errors

    ↓

    Incorrect customer orders

    ↓

    Higher service costs

    ↓

    Customer dissatisfaction

    The apparent customer-service problem is partly an upstream operations problem.


    From Analysis to Strategic Alternatives

    The value chain suggests several potential alternatives.

    Alternative 1: Centralise Procurement

    Use greater purchasing scale to reduce input costs and improve consistency.

    Alternative 2: Standardise Operations

    Redesign meal assembly and packaging processes to reduce errors and labour requirements.

    Alternative 3: Invest in Technology

    Integrate procurement, inventory, production, and order management.

    Alternative 4: Redesign Delivery

    Partner with a logistics provider or redesign delivery zones to reduce last-mile costs.

    The alternatives should then be evaluated against:

    • cost savings;

    • customer impact;

    • implementation difficulty;

    • investment requirements;

    • strategic importance;

    • risk; and

    • speed of impact.

    The value chain has identified where to look.

    It has not automatically identified what to do.


    Prioritising Value Chain Improvements

    You will rarely have enough resources to improve everything.

    Prioritise improvement opportunities basedusing on:four questions:

    ·

    1. Customer Impact:Impact

    How strongly does the activity affect something customers value?

    2. Economic Impact

    ·        Financial Impact: How significantlystrongly does itimproving affectthe revenue,activity cost,affect:

    margin,
    • revenue;

    • cost;

    • margin;

    • working capital,capital; or

    • profitability?

    3. Strategic Importance

    Could this activity create or investment?strengthen competitive advantage?

    ·

    4. Performance Gap: How far is current performance from customer expectations, organisational targets, or competitor performance?

    Feasibility

    ·        Downstream Influence: How many other activities are affected by the problem?

    ·        Feasibility: Can the organisation realistically improve the activity using available resources, time, skills, and technology?it?

    ·        Strategic Importance: Could improving the activity strengthen the organisation's competitive position?

    A simpleuseful prioritisation tablematrix might look like this:is:


    ActivityHigh Feasibility

    Low

    Customer impactFeasibility

    Financial impact

    Downstream influence

    Improvement potential

    High

    Demand forecasting

    Impact

    High

    Prioritise
    Strategic

    High

    High

    High

    Investment
    Low

    Packaging

    Impact
    Quick

    Moderate

    Win

    Moderate

    Low

    Moderate

    Order fulfilment

    High

    High

    High

    High

    Payroll administration

    Low

    Low

    Low

    Moderate

    Customer onboarding

    High

    Moderate

    Moderate

    High

    Deprioritise

    The objectivegoal is not to assignimprove aevery perfectactivity.

    score.

    It is to determine where intervention could create the greatest strategic value.

    Choosing the Improvement Approach

    Once the team identifies an important activity, it must decide how to change it.

    ·        Strengthen: Invest in the activity's people, resources, training, technology, or capacity. Use this when the activity is strategically important but underperforming.

    ·        Redesign: Change the sequence, responsibilities, handoffs, or structure of the activity. Use this when the current process creates delay, duplication, confusion, or poor customer outcomes.

    ·        Automate: Use technology to perform repeatable work, improve accuracy, or accelerate information flow. Use this when the process is stable, rules are clear, and automation will not remove important human judgement or customer interaction.

    ·        Outsource: Move the activity to an external provider. Use this when the activity is not strategically distinctive, and another organisation can perform it more efficiently or effectively.

    ·        Integrate: Bring an activity closer to the organisation, potentially through ownership, partnership, shared systems, or tighter coordination. Use this when dependence on an external organisation creates high cost, risk, delay, or loss of control.

    ·        Eliminate: Remove work that doesn't create value, enable value, or meet a requirement. Use this when the activity is genuinely unnecessary, not simply because customers cannot see it.

    ·        Standardise: Create consistent procedures, tools, roles, and performance expectations. Use this when variation results in errors, costs, or inconsistent service.

    ·        Differentiate: Invest more heavily in an activity that strongly influences customer preference or competitive advantage. Use this when the activity can create meaningful value that competitors struggle to match.

    Before Recommending Automation, Outsourcing, or Integration

    These choices require more than identifying an inefficient activity.

    Before Automating, Ask:

    • Is the process already well understood?
    • Are the rules consistent?
    • Will automation remove errors or accelerate them?
    • What system integration is required?
    • What happens when exceptions occur?
    • Will the change improve or damage the customer experience?
    • Does the organisation have the required data and skills?

    Don't automate a broken process before redesigning it.

    Before Outsourcing, Ask:

    • Is the activity strategically important?
    • Does it contain valuable customer knowledge?
    • Could outsourcing weaken quality or control?
    • How dependent would the organisation become on the provider?
    • What coordination and monitoring costs would remain?
    • What happens if the provider fails?
    • Is the apparent saving based on total cost or only direct cost?

    Lower direct cost doesn't always mean lower total cost.

    Before Integrating, Ask:

    • Is the activity important enough to own or control more closely?
    • Would integration reduce costs, risks, or dependencies?
    • Does the organisation have the capability to perform it?
    • What investment would be required?
    • Would ownership reduce flexibility?
    • Could a partnership achieve the same result with less risk?

    These questions prevent teams from recommending fashionable solutions without understanding their operational consequences.

    A Worked Example

    Consider the regional meal-kit company introduced in Chapter 11. The Five Forces analysis showed:

    • intense rivalry;
    • high buyer power;
    • strong substitutes;
    • limited ability to compete through price;
    • a potential advantage based on local supplier relationships.

    The company is also experiencing:

    • late deliveries;
    • food waste;
    • high refund rates;
    • customer complaints;
    • declining margins.

    Step 1: Define Customer Value

    The target customer values:

    • convenience;
    • fresh local ingredients;
    • reliable delivery;
    • easy meal preparation;
    • flexibility.

    Step 2: Map the Activities

    ·        The company's simplified value chain is:

    ·        Supplier selection → Demand forecasting → Ingredient purchasing → Meal planning and assembly → Order fulfilment → Delivery → Customer support → Retention

    Support activities include:

    • supplier management;
    • employee scheduling;
    • technology;
    • procurement;
    • financial planning.

    Step 3: Identify Performance Gaps

    The team finds:

    • forecasts are based largely on historical averages;
    • promotions are not incorporated into purchasing plans;
    • meal variety increases ingredient complexity;
    • orders are changed until shortly before assembly;
    • delivery partners receive route information late;
    • customer service cannot see accurate order status;
    • complaint information is not shared consistently with operations.

    Step 4: Connect the Activities

    The problems are not independent: Inaccurate forecasting → excess ingredients for some meals and shortages for others → last-minute menu substitutions → assembly delays → late route information → delivery delays → customer complaints and refunds → lower retention and higher acquisition pressure. The visible problems delivery delays and complaints originate partly in forecasting, menu complexity, and information flow.

    Step 5: Identify the Strategic Implication

    The company should not begin by hiring more customer-service employees or replacing the delivery partner.

    The stronger response is to redesign the connected system.

    Possible actions include:

    • integrate promotion and ordering data into forecasting;
    • reduce low-demand meal options;
    • establish earlier order-change deadlines;
    • provide delivery partners with earlier route data;
    • connect customer service to real-time order status;
    • create a feedback loop from complaints to operations and meal planning.

    Step 6: Connect Improvement to Strategy

    The redesign would:

    • reduce food waste;
    • lower refund and expediting costs;
    • improve delivery reliability;
    • strengthen the convenience customers value;
    • improve retention;
    • support differentiation based on reliable local meal delivery.

    The analysis has moved from operational symptoms to a strategic solution.

    Value Chain Analysis Is Not the Recommendation

    Mapping the value chain doesn't determine what the organisation should do. A complete process is:

    1. define what the customer values;
    2. map the activities involved in creating and delivering that value;
    3. assess cost, quality, speed, reliability, and differentiation;
    4. identify bottlenecks and weak handoffs;
    5. trace symptoms to upstream causes;
    6. identify the activitieshighest-leverage most important to customer and financial outcomes;
    7. generate improvement alternatives;
    8. evaluate feasibility, investment, risk, and organisational implications;
    9. select the strongest course of action;
    10. develop an implementation and performance-measurement plan.

    Value Chain Analysis helps locate the opportunity. It doesn't replace financial analysis, alternative evaluation, change planning, or implementation design.opportunities.

    Turning


    Analysis into Action

    A recommendation based on Value Chain Analysis should identify:

    • the activity being changed;
    • the problem or opportunity;
    • the root cause;
    • the proposed intervention;
    • the activities and stakeholders affected;
    • the required capabilities and investment;
    • the implementation sequence;
    • the major risks;
    • the measures used to determine success.

    Instead of recommending: Improve delivery. Recommend: Integrate order and routing data, establish a daily route-confirmation deadline, and pilot zone-based delivery scheduling in the company's largest market. Measure on-time delivery, cost per delivery, failed-delivery rates, complaints, and customer retention before expanding the model. The second recommendation is actionable because it is grounded in the value chain.

    Measuring the Improvement

    The measures should match the activity and the value being created.

    Cost Measures

    • cost per unit;
    • labour cost per transaction;
    • transportation cost;
    • procurement savings;
    • inventory carrying cost;
    • cost of rework;
    • refund cost;
    • cost to serve.

    Quality Measures

    • defect rate;
    • error rate;
    • return rate;
    • first-contact resolution;
    • customer complaints;
    • compliance rate.

    Speed Measures

    • cycle time;
    • order-processing time;
    • delivery time;
    • response time;
    • waiting time;
    • time to market.

    Reliability Measures

    • on-time delivery;
    • forecast accuracy;
    • inventory availability;
    • schedule adherence;
    • uptime;
    • service consistency.

    Customer Measures

    • satisfaction;
    • retention;
    • repeat purchase;
    • Net Promoter Score;
    • conversion;
    • customer effort;
    • lifetime value.

    Strategic Measures

    • market share;
    • price premium;
    • capability development;
    • channel access;
    • supplier resilience;
    • differentiation.

    A strong implementation plan uses a small number of measures linked directly to the intended improvement.

    Winning the Room: Presenting Value Chain Analysis

    A completetraditional value-value chain diagram can quickly become crowded.complicated Thequickly.

    judges don't need

    Showing every activity may demonstrate that the team examined. They need to understand:

    • whereknows the importantframework.

      problem

      It occurs;

    • may
    • whatnot causesdemonstrate it;
    • that
    • howthe itteam affectsunderstands otherthe activities;
    • business.

    • what

      Instead, itidentify:

      costs

      Where Value Is Created

      What does the organisation do particularly well?

      Where Value Is Lost

      Where are customers experiencing problems or customer;

    • where
    • howis the recommendationorganisation fixesconsuming it.
    • unnecessary
    resources?

    Where Value Can Be Strengthened

    StartWhich improvements could create the greatest strategic or economic impact?

    For example:

    Three Value Chain Priorities

    1. Procurement

    Fragmented purchasing increases ingredient costs.

    2. Operations

    Manual processes create errors and rework.

    3. Technology

    Disconnected systems prevent accurate demand and inventory planning.

    Strategic Implication

    Integrating procurement, inventory, and production planning could reduce waste while improving order accuracy and customer experience.

    That is more persuasive than showing ten boxes.


    Coach's Lens

    I often tell teams:

    Don't map the value chain because the framework tells you to. Map it because you want to find the leverage points.

    A leverage point is an activity where a relatively focused intervention can produce a meaningful improvement elsewhere in the system.

    The strongest teams don't simply identify:

    "This activity is inefficient."

    They explain:

    This activity is causing problems downstream, and fixing it will improve cost, customer experience, and competitive position.

    That is strategic thinking.


    Common Mistakes

    1. Treating the Value Chain as a Process Map

    A process map tells you what happens.

    A value chain analysis asks:

    Why does it matter?


    2. Listing Activities Without Evaluating Them

    "The company has procurement, operations, marketing, and service."

    That is description.

    Identify value, cost, performance, and strategic importance.


    3. Assuming Every Activity Must Add Customer Value

    Some activities are necessary support activities.

    The question is whether they contribute effectively to the organisation's value proposition.


    4. Focusing Only on Cost

    The cheapest process is not always the best process.

    Consider customer value and strategic capability.


    Problems often originate upstream and appear downstream.

    Look for the connections.


    6. Fixing Symptoms Instead of Root Causes

    Late deliveries may be a logistics problem.

    They may also be caused by poor forecasting, scheduling, technology, or procurement.


    7. Treating Every Improvement as Equally Important

    Prioritise the activities with the Valuegreatest Beingcustomer, Losteconomic, strategic, and feasible impact.


    8. Assuming Efficiency Creates Sustainable Advantage

    An efficient process may be valuable without being rare or difficult to imitate.

    ForThat example,is customerswhere chooseVRIO becomes important.


    9. Ignoring Support Activities

    Technology, people, procurement, and infrastructure can have enormous effects on primary activities.


    10. Assuming Outsourcing Is Automatically Better

    Outsourcing may reduce cost.

    But it may also reduce control, quality, flexibility, or strategic capability.


    11. Assuming Automation Always Creates Value

    Automation is useful when it improves the companyeconomics foror convenience,customer but delivery unreliability undermines that value proposition.experience.

    ShowAutomating a bad process can simply make the Criticalbad Chainprocess faster.


    12. Stopping at the Analysis

    InsteadThe purpose of presenting every activity, show the connection that matters: Forecasting error → inventory shortage → fulfilment delay → late delivery → complaint and refund

    Quantify the Impact

    Where possible, connect the problem to:

    • cost;
    • time;
    • quality;
    • capacity;
    • customer satisfaction;
    • retention;
    • revenue.

    Connect the Improvement to the Strategy

    Complete the argument: Integrating order, inventory, and routing information will reduce fulfilment delays while strengthening the reliable convenience that differentiates the company. The analytical chain becomes: Customer Value → Operational Cause → Business Impact → Strategic Improvement.

    Coach's Lens

    Value Chain Analysis is oneto ofidentify where the bestorganisation toolscan for stopping teams from recommending vague operational improvements. "Reduce costs," "improve efficiency," and "enhance customer service" are not complete recommendations. Ask:improve.

      Always

    • Whichask:

      activity
      must change?
    • What is causing the problem?

    • What other activities will be affected?
    • What value will the change create?
    • How willshould we know it worked?

    Value Chain Analysis can also surface core competencies.

    ·        Ask: What does this organisation do exceptionally well?

    ·        Then ask: Is it valuable to customers?

    ·        And finally, can competitors easily replicate the activity or the system of activities that supports it?

    Those questions move the analysis from operational performance toward competitive advantage.

    Common Mistakes

    ·        Mapping Without Analysing: Listing activities doesn't reveal where value is created or lost. Evaluate the cost, quality, speed, reliability, and customer contribution for each key activity.

    ·        Treating Every Activity Equally: Some activities have much greater customer, financial, or strategic impact than others; prioritise based on customer impact, financial impact, downstream impact, performance gap, and feasibility.

    ·        Focusing Only on Cost: An activity may create differentiation, trust, convenience, or loyalty even if it is expensive. Examine both cost advantage and differentiation.

    ·        Ignoring Connections: Improving one department's performance may create problems elsewhere. Trace the flow of information, materials, decisions, and customer feedback across activities.

    ·        Confusing Symptoms with Causes: The activity experiencing the problem may not be the activity causing it. Trace visible problems upstream through the value chain.

    ·        Forgetting the Customer: An activity mattersdifferently because of thewhat valuewe it ultimately creates, enables, or protects. Define customer value before judging the activity.learned?

    · Treating


    Activities as Capabilities: Performing an activity doesn't automatically create competitive advantage. Determine whether the organisation performs or distinctively connects activities.

    ·        Recommending Automation Too Quickly: Technology can accelerate a poorly designed process. Simplify and redesign the process before automating it.

    ·        Recommending Outsourcing Based Only on Direct Cost: Outsourcing may introduce coordination costs, dependency, quality risks, and knowledge loss. Evaluate the total cost and strategic importance.

    ·        Ignoring Support Activities: A visible operational problem may originate in training, technology, procurement, incentives, or organisational structure. Examine the support system that enables the primary activities.

    ·        Forcing the Original Categories: A manufacturing-oriented model may not fit a service, digital, public-sector, or not-for-profit organisation. Adapt the value chain to how the organisation actually creates value.

    ·        Stopping at the Diagram: The map is not the recommendation. Translate findings into a specific intervention, an implementation sequence, and performance measures.

    MAD Skills Drill

    Choose an organisation and complete

    Find the followingLeverage steps.Point

    Choose a company or business case.

    Step 1: Define Customerthe Value Proposition

    Complete:

    Customers choose this organisation because __________.

    Identify the twoone or threetwo thingsattributes thecustomers target customer valuesvalue most.

    Step 2: Map the Value Chain

    Identify the major activities requiredinvolved to:in:

    • design;

      acquiring inputs;

    • create;

      producing or delivering the offering;

    • sell;

      reaching customers;

    • deliver;

      selling;

    • support

      servicing customers; and

    • supporting the offering.organisation.

    Include the most important support activities.

    Step 3: AssessIdentify Eachthe Activity

    Gaps

    For each major activity, consider:ask:

    • cost;

      What should happen?

    • quality;

      What actually happens?

    • speed;
    • reliability;
    • What

    • customeris impact;
    • the
    • differentiation.performance gap?

    Step 4: IdentifyTrace Fourthe PriorityProblem

    Activities

    Choose one important gap.

    Identify:Ask:

    • What causes it?

    • Then:

      What does it cause downstream?

      Build an impact chain.

      Step 5: Identify the Leverage Point

      Which activity creatingcould thebe mostimproved customerto value;

    • the activity producingcreate the greatest cost;
    • overall
    • the activity contributing most to competitive advantage; and
    • the activity offering the greatest opportunity for improvement.

    These may or may not be the same activity.impact?

    Step 5: Trace One Important Connection

    Select one performance problem and trace it: Symptom → Activity → Upstream Cause → Downstream Consequence.

    Step 6: Generate ThreeStrategic Improvement Options

    Actions

    Consider whether the activity should be:

    • strengthened;

      redesigned;

    • redesigned;

      automated;

    • automated;

      outsourced;

    • outsourced;

      insourced;

    • integrated;

    • standardised;

      eliminated; or

    • differentiated;
    • eliminated.

      strengthened through investment.

    Step 7: Test the Wider Impact

    Prioritise

    ForEvaluate eachyour option,proposed ask:improvement based on:

    • What other

      customer activitiesimpact;

      will be affected?
    • What new

      economic costsimpact;

      or risks might be created?
    • Will customer

      strategic valueimportance; improveand

      or decline?
    • What capabilities

      feasibility.

      will be required?

    Step 8: Deliver the Insight

    You have 90 seconds to explain:

    PrepareWhere a 60-second explanation answering:

    1. What does the customer value?
    2. Wherevalue is that value being created or→ lost?
    3. where
    4. Whatit activityis orlost connection→ what is causing the problem?
    5. problem
    6. What→ shouldwhere the leverage point is → what the organisation change?
    7. What result should thatdo.

      change produce?

    Don'tDo not simply present the entirevalue value-chainchain.

    map. Present

    Explain the part ofstory the value chain that changed your recommendation.reveals.


    Chapter Summary

    Value Chain Analysis helps move the case teamsanalysis understandinside the organisation.

    It examines how activities contribute to:

    • customer value;

    • cost;

    • quality;

    • speed;

    • differentiation;

    • competitive advantage; and

    • profitability.

    The most valuable analysis does not simply map activities.

    It identifies:

    Where value is created → where value is lost → why the gap exists → where the leverage point is → how value can be strengthened.

    Value chain activities are interconnected.

    An apparently isolated problem may have upstream causes and downstream consequences.

    The strongest solutions therefore look for system-level improvements, not isolated fixes.

    Value Chain Analysis also connects naturally to other tools:

    • Five Forces explains competitive pressure.

    • SWOT identifies strategic position.

    • Value Chain identifies where value and cost are created.

    • VRIO examines whether capabilities can create sustainable advantage.

    • Financial Analysis determines whether improvements create economic value.

    Together, these tools create a more complete picture of how an organisation competes.


    Key Takeaways

    ✓ Value Chain Analysis examines the activities through which an organisation creates and delivers valuevalue.

    through

    ✓ aPrimary connectedactivities systemdirectly ofcontribute activities.to Itscreating and delivering the offering; support activities enable those activities to perform effectively.

    ✓ Start with the customer value doesn'tproposition comebefore frommapping listing functions. It comes from identifying:activities.

      ✓

    • what customers value;
    • whichEvaluate activities createbased oron enablecustomer that value;
    • wherevalue, cost, delay,performance, error, or inconsistency originates;
    • how activities affect one another;
    • which capabilities support competitive advantage;
    • where operational orand strategic redesign could have the greatest impact.

    Strong Value Chain Analysis follows this progression: Customer Value → Activity → Performance Gap → Connection → Root Cause → Strategic Improvement. importance.Activities must not be evaluated in isolation. A change in procurement may affect quality.

    ·✓ ALook changefor inperformance product variety may affect inventory and fulfilment. A

    ·        technology change may affect employees and customers.

    ·        A service change may reveal a problem that began much earlier in the chain.

    A weak Value Chain analysis maps what the organisation does. A strong Value Chain analysis explains what the organisation should change and why.

    Key Takeaways

    ✓ Value Chain Analysis examines how connected organisational activities create, deliver, enable, or protect customer value.

    ✓ Begin by defining what the target customer valuesgaps rather than beginningsimply withlisting the organisation's departments.activities.

    ✓ Adapt the value chain to the organisation instead of forcing a manufacturing organisation's model in every case.

    ✓ Analyse both primary activities and the support activities that enable them.

    ✓ Distinguish activities from capabilities. Competitive advantage comes from performing or connecting activities in distinctive ways.

    ✓ Examine cost, quality, speed, reliability, customer impact, and differentiation.

    ✓ Trace visible performance problems upstream to identify their root causes.causes and downstream to understand consequences.

    ✓ FocusValue on connectionscreation and handoffsvalue becausecapture are not always the greatestsame weaknessthing.

    may

    ✓ existThe strongest opportunities often occur at the connections between activities.

    ✓ PrioritiseConsider redesign, automation, outsourcing, insourcing, integration, elimination, and investment as possible improvement opportunitieslevers.

    ✓ Prioritise improvements based on customer impact, financialeconomic impact, performance gap, downstream influence, strategic importance, and feasibility.

    ✓ ConsiderAn whetherefficient activitiesactivity shouldis benot strengthened,automatically redesigned,a automated,sustainable outsourced,competitive integrated,advantage—connect standardised,important differentiated,capabilities orto eliminated.VRIO.

    ✓ Don't automate a broken process or outsource a strategically important capability without understanding the consequences.

    ✓ Translate Value Chain findings into a specific intervention, implementation sequence, and set of performance measures.

    ✓ In the presentation, show where value is created, where it is lost, and where the criticalhighest-leverage connectionimprovement lies.


    Bottom Line

    Don't map the value chain just to show that changedyou understand the recommendation,framework. notUse everyit activityto infind the organisation.activities that create value, destroy value, and offer the greatest opportunity to strengthen the organisation's competitive position.


    Looking Ahead

    Value Chain Analysis can reveal the activities and capabilities that enableallow an organisation to create value, reducelower costs,cost, improve performance, or differentiate itself.

    The

    But nextan important question isremains:

    whichWhich of those capabilities can create a sustainable competitive advantage?

    The next chapter introduces VRIO Analysis, which evaluateshelps determine whether aan resourceorganisation's orresources capabilityand iscapabilities valuable,are rare,Valuable, inimitable,Rare, difficult to Imitate, and supported by the organisation.Organisation—and therefore whether they can become a source of sustained competitive advantage.