Skip to main content

Case Study: News Media Today

Case Study: News Media Today

LEARNING OUTCOMES

  • Discuss the importance of evaluating sources and understanding biases
  • Describe the components of the CRAAP analysis process

News media sources, such as a TV news report, must be carefully scrutinized. Here we refer to news media as major news networks, such as CNN or Fox News, local television news, and other televised news programs. These sources are unfortunately not above the tension and issues possible with less established sources. An April 2018 video criticizing Sinclair Broadcast Group highlights the dubious nature of our contemporary media landscape.

The following two videos discuss the fallout and tension:

Interestingly, the discussion has become deeply politicized. Whether the material presented is conservative or liberal is interesting, but our purpose here is to highlight how media is a contested space; it is just as difficult to get quality information here as anywhere else, and the information presented through media must be scrutinized like any other source.

Evaluation

As with evaluating websites, evaluating other media sources with the CRAAP method is appropriate. There are, however, a few added questions specific to media that you should add to Currency, your CRAAP (Currency, Relevancy, Authority, Accuracy, and Purpose.

Who is the owner of the media outlet?

The above example is about Sinclair Broadcasting Group. Take a look at WebpageFX’s infographic of ownership of key outlets. As you view the infographic, consider applying the CRAAP Analysis to WebpageFX. Is it a good source? Why or why not?

Figure 1 shows the consolidation of media ownership in the United States over a 30 year span.With consolidation of outlets, the plurality of available media and variation in beliefs and political stances represented has diminished.

Two pie charts comparing ownership of media in America between 1983 and 2011. In 1983 90% of the market was owned by 50 companies. In 2011 90% of the market was owned by 6 companies.


Figure 1. Media consolidation from 1983 to 2011

In plural democracies like the US and other Western nations, this is certainly a concern. To what extent do the media play a role in homogenizing American life? To what extent should we be concerned this affects our freedom and ability to live and exist with others with whom we might disagree, yet arguably should respect?

How long has the media outlet been around?

While not a perfect test of quality by any means, consider how something like 60 Minutes, the news magazine from CBS, has been on the air for over 40 years. Would this make it more or less reputable than, for example, a newer YouTube news channel, e.g., The Young Turks or The Rubin Report.

In the above discussion, we noted how quickly the use of media becomes politicized. Consider the use of mass media sources carefully given this potential problem. A good technique would be to simply address what you (as the researcher) think the bias might be. As we’ve discussed elsewhere, it’s not as simple as saying all bias is bad, but rather, bias is something we all encounter and have, and it is reasonable and useful to address bias head-on. The researcher should tell the reader what their biases are; the researcher should tell the reader what they think a given source’s biases are as well. The onus is on the reader always to think critically on the material presented.


LICENSES AND ATTRIBUTIONS
CC LICENSED CONTENT, ORIGINAL
  • Media Literacy and Fact Checking. Authored by: Freedom Learning Group. Provided by: Lumen Learning. License: CC BY: Attribution
  • Media consolidation chart. Authored by: Freedom Learning Group. Provided by: Lumen Learning. License: CC BY: Attribution
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED CONTENT
No Comments
Back to top